Redlisting of Mediterranean cetacean populations

 

Given their sheer number, assessing all geographic populations of cetaceans (sub-populations, in Red List-speak) is a long-term challenge; only a small fraction have been assessed, with priority given to those suspected of being in the most trouble. Two regions where relatively good progress has been made in recent years are the Mediterranean and Black Seas thanks to a joint effort by ACCOBAMS (the CMS Agreement on the Conservation of Cetaceans of the Black Sea, Mediterranean Sea, and Contiguous Atlantic Area) and the Cetacean Specialist Group.

The first subpopulation in the region to have been assessed formally under the modern quantitative Red List categories and criteria was the Mediterranean short-beaked common dolphin, Delphinus delphis, which was redlisted in 2003 as Endangered (A2abc). The assessment was drafted by Giovanni Bearzi, who had become especially motivated when he witnessed the almost complete disappearance of the species from one of his study areas, off western Greece, likely as a result of prey depletion due to overfishing.

In 2008, the assessment produced by Alexei Birkun, Jr. and Alexandros Frantzis of Black Sea harbour porpoises, Phocoena phocoena relicta, was finalised. This subspecies is found in the Black Sea and also occurs in the Marmara Sea and in portions of the Aegean Sea, well inside the Mediterranean. Harbour porpoises in the Black Sea were subjected to very large legal direct takes until 1983, and to continued illegal hunting until at least 1991. They still suffer from extensive incidental mortality in bottom-set gillnets. This history of heavy exploitation, together with ongoing threats, led the subspecies to be redlisted as Endangered (A1d+4cde).

In 2012, several additional Mediterranean sub-population assessments were published, namely:

  • sperm whales, Physeter macrocephalus, listed as Endangered (C2a(ii)), assessed by Giuseppe Notarbartolo di Sciara, Alexandros Frantzis, Giovanni Bearzi and Randall R. Reeves;
  • fin whales, Balaenoptera physalus, listed as Vulnerable (C2a(ii)), assessed by Simone Panigada and Giuseppe Notarbartolo di Sciara;
  • striped dolphins, Stenella coeruleoalba, listed as Vulnerable (A2bcde), assessed by Alex Aguilar and Stefania Gaspari;
  • common bottlenose dolphins, Tursiops truncatus, listed as Vulnerable (A2cde), assessed by Giovanni Bearzi, Caterina Fortuna, and Randall R. Reeves;
  • Cuvier’s beaked whales, Ziphius cavirostris, listed as Data Deficient, assessed by Ana Cañadas;
  • long-finned pilot whales Globicephala melas, listed as Data Deficient, assessed by Ana Cañadas; and
  • Risso’s dolphins Grampus griseus, listed as Data Deficient, assessed by Stefania Gaspari and Ana Natoli.

Assessment of the Gibraltar subpopulation of Orcinus orca is not yet completed.

Conservation of cetaceans and manatees in Western Africa

 

A new publication on cetaceans and manatees in the Western African region has just been published by CMS. The publication is a compilation of articles presented at the scientific symposium ‘Western African Talks on Cetaceans and their Habitats (WATCH)’ held in Adeje, Tenerife in 2007. The document includes detailed information on marine mammals of the African eastern Atlantic basin, a region from which cetaceans are poorly known.

At the same meeting a ‘Memorandum of Understanding on Small Cetaceans and Manatees of West Africa’ was developed. The signatory Governments agreed ‘to work closely together in the region and to foster cooperation, build capacity and ensure coordinated region-wide actions to achieve and maintain a favourable conservation status for manatees and small cetaceans and their habitats and to safeguard the associated values of these species for the people of the region’.

An ‘Action Plan for the Conservation of Small Cetaceans of Western Africa and Macaronesia’ was also developed at the scientific symposium. The Action Plan attempts to balance the interests of local communities and fishermen and the socio-economic development of the region, with the need to reduce or eliminate threats to cetaceans and their habitats in order to ensure their conservation.

The scientific symposium, MoU, Action Plan have brought much needed attention to the assessment and conservation of the small-cetacean fauna of the eastern tropical Atlantic.

Update on Conservation Efforts for the Vaquita

 

In 1997, the Government of México convened a committee of international experts (CIRVA) to advise it on methods to save its endemic porpoise, the vaquita, from extinction. CIRVA met for the fourth time, in February 2012, in Ensenada, México.

CIRVA recognized that since 2008 México established a Vaquita Refuge in the core of the vaquita’s distribution and initiated a scheme of monetary compensation to eliminate gillnetting and industrial trawling within this Refuge. That scheme reduced, but did not eliminate, un-permitted fishing. The Government of Mexico, with significant support and funding from US government agencies and other groups, conducted a new survey of vaquita abundance, established an acoustics program to monitor population trends, and developed an alternative, “vaquita-safe” method for catching shrimp.  Never before has so much serious effort and funding been invested to protect the vaquita. Without these efforts, vaquitas might already have reached a state where recovery would not be possible.

However, information presented at the February 2012 meeting showed that the vaquita population is still declining and now likely consists of fewer than 200 individuals. The Vaquita Refuge protects only about half of the population and illegal gillnet fishing is still common inside the Refuge. Also, gillnets are still commonly used to catch shrimp and finfish outside the Refuge. CIRVA concluded that if the continuing decline in vaquita abundance is not halted within the next five years (by 2017), the species may be too depleted to ever recover.

Based on information presented at this meeting, CIRVA made a number of recommendations, the most important being:

 

  • All gillnets and other entangling nets need to be removed from the vaquita’s entire range.
  • Artisanal shrimp fishing vessels should be converted immediately from using gillnets to using small trawls.
  • Additional research is needed to develop vaquita-safe methods to fish for finfish with artisanal vessels. Spatial management measures are needed that provide access incentives for shrimp fishermen who use small trawls rather than gillnets.
  • A legal limit on the length of gillnets and the number of nets per vessel needs to be enforced for fisheries with such limits, like the shrimp fishery.
  • A legal limit on the length of gillnets and the number of nets per vessel needs to be established and enforced for all other fisheries (besides the shrimp fishery).
  • More effective enforcement of no-fishing regulations within the Vaquita Refuge is needed.
  • The boundaries of the Vaquita Refuge should be changed as described in the report.
  • The current acoustic monitoring scheme should continue for at least the first planned 5-year period so that vaquita population trends can be tracked and recovery strategies adapted accordingly.

The full report of the workshop is available here: